SeamlessWeb allows you to enjoy convenient online ordering from the best local restaurants. If you're ordering for the first time, start your order by entering your address to the right. Return users log in here.
192 EAST 2ND STREET, (2nd & Avenue B)(212) 228-3710
Minimum order of $12.00 is required for delivery.
Restaurant's delivery estimate is 25 - 40 min. More info
Print this menu
All salads served with balsamic vinegar and olive oil on the side.
Il Bagatto is a traditional-style Italian restaurant serving an extensive menu filled with classic favorites and supplemented by their daily specials. They pride themselves on making each diner's experience fantastic, and have created a close, romantic atmosphere in which to offer their food. Il Bagatto’s attentive and friendly wait staff will insure you enjoy your meal, and their full bar means that they are the perfect place for a date or a night out with friends.
Calamari alla Grillia—Grilled calamari
Salmone Affumicato e Brie Panini—Smoked salmon, Brie and watercress
Penne All’Arabbiata—Penne served in a spicy tomato sauce
Tacchino Panini—Roasted turkey breast, frisee salad and roasted peppers
Cotoletta Condita—Chicken cutlet breaded in focaccia crumbs, topped with fresh Mozzarella, tomatoes and Arugula
Tiramisu
Super yummy!! wasn't piping hot on arrival but the outstanding flavors and fresh ingredients more than made up for it, My new go to for Italian.
Posted 2 weeks ago by Torya B.
This is hands down the best italian food I have ever had. The boccini and prosciutto is godly. Highly recommended. Probably the best restaurant on Seamless Web, at least in my area.
Posted 2 weeks ago by Ryan D.
Favorite Italian restaurant in the city. Love it. The only drawback is they only take cash an Amex.
Posted a month ago by Lauren H.
By far the best Italian on Seamless Web for my delivery area (Soho). Food is delivered quickly and it's always hot. I've had most of their pastas and they are all incredible. They also have great paninis for lunch.
Posted a month ago by Nicole P.
The food here is really great. The bruschetta is pretty large and excellent.
Posted a month ago by Vijay P.
the food was pipin' hot when it got here. highly recommended.
Posted 3 months ago by Analia S.
The food was good but arrived well over an hour. I called to inquire after an hour and was put on hold for several minutes. The restaurant put the same exact order on my account twice and the delivery came two times, one hour apart. I called the restaurant and I think they credited back my account, but this was the most annoying seamlessweb experience I've ever had. There are too many good restaurants in NYC that are prompt, smart and have good food.
Posted 3 months ago by Jon R.
My favorite Italian in the neighborhood. Not just "passable" take-out food, but top-rate cuisine.
Posted 3 months ago by Bradley D.
I had no idea what to expect, but I was definitely thrilled and delighted by what I got! Both the antipasto Il Bagatto and homemade fettucine special were delicious. The food embodies Italian food at its finest - uncomplicated dishes sustained by the freshness and quality of their ingredients. Order from this place - I highly recommend it!
Posted 4 months ago by Toma B.
Good food, but I really wish they would change the menu every once in a while, or mix up more of their specials.
Posted 4 months ago by Allison G.
I find it difficult to accept that this was considered edible food. How can an Italian restaurant deliver mushy pasta with indiscriminate taste and ingredients? Flavorless, soggy and watery salmon with penne... I generally read the reviews before placing my order somewhere, and this had said that they had "great italian food, especially for the price"- which I must respectfully disagree with. If you consider the Olive Garden to be a classy and authentic NYC Italian restaurant; then by all means, order this sludge for dinner.
Posted 4 months ago by Erin C.
This is my favorite Italian restaurant in the city. Amazing.
Posted 5 months ago by alessandra k.
good pasta. meat was inedible. so tough I could not even make it half way through the veal dish
Posted 6 months ago by Claire F.
The food was great and delivery took less than 20 minutes. I had Penne ala Vodka - it was hot and fresh when it arrived!
Posted 8 months ago by Nancy H.
while the food is OK, the delivery is ridiculous--- they dont bring utensils unless you specify it in the order, they dont have straws (period), and they took an additional 45 minutes to bring me the proper utensils after i called them and complained that they werent included.
Posted 8 months ago by Laura H.
great penne alla vodka
Posted a year ago by Eugene B.
excellent food, excellent service, five stars
Posted a year ago by antonio t.
Great! Very tasty. I highly recommend it. Only issue was slow delivery time.
Posted a year ago by Warren W.
I've ordered salads, pastas, and fish from here and it is always amazing. Favorites are: Fusilli Campagnolak and the grilled salmon. (The tiramisu is pretty decent as well. Chocolate cake dessert thing...not so much.)
Posted 2 years ago by Christine H.
Took over an hour and a half to get order, then was missing a dish, then had to deal with RUDE service people at the restaurant. Mandatory tip AND EXPENSIVE for mediocre food.
Posted 2 years ago by Li L.
southern rustic italian, tons of seafood, impeccable service... very very good.
Posted 2 years ago by Stephen M.
I wish they would change the menu every once in a while.
Posted 2 years ago by Pamela Y.
Other than it is the cutest restaurant, their food is unbelievable!! Especially their nine-layered lasagna, which is only served on Sundays for dinner. It is HEAVENLY! You HAVE to try this place!
Posted 3 years ago
We order them for delivery all the time and not once have I ever been disappointed. Their frisse salad with marinated goat cheese is my favorite salad ever created. With Il Baggato you can't go wrong.
Only select user reviews are published on SeamlessWeb. All user-submitted ratings contribute to Il Bagatto's overall SeamlessWeb rating, but we manually screen all reviews and only publish those that are relevant and helpful. Tips for getting your review published »
Above content provided by restaurant.
Enter your address to start your order.
Click a menu item to add it to your order.
Learn more about Liked Items »
Back to top