SeamlessWeb allows you to enjoy convenient online ordering from the best local restaurants. If you're ordering for the first time, start your order by entering your address to the right. Return users log in here.
416 8TH AVENUE (31st & 8th )(212) 967-7603
Minimum order of $15.00 is required for delivery.
Restaurant's delivery estimate is 20 - 35 min. More info
Print this menu
Served with 1 side and pickles.
Choice of one side plus pickles. Served on a white bun.
A half rack served with 2 sides, cornbread and pickles.
Served with 2 sides (except where noted), cornbread and pickles.
Served with 2 sides, cornbread and pickles.
Although Brother Jimmy’s offers a diverse menu of many Southern favorites, they are most famous for their traditional Southern BBQ. All of their BBQ is smoked in-house, using Cookshack-brand Smokers. Even the hickory wood they use to smoke the meat is shipped straight from the South. Everything is smoked slowly and carefully—up to 10 hours!—in order to get the best tasting, juiciest BBQ in town.
Read more
Since first opening in 1988, Brother Jimmy's has established itself as a New York legend, bringing down home cookin’ and good times from the South to New York City. Their restaurants continue to thrive, and the number of happy customers continues to grow. Wherever people are hungry for good BBQ, wherever they suffer under the oppression of bad food and boredom, Brother Jimmy's will be there, "puttin' some South in their mouth!"
Hide
Combo Rib Platters—Your choice of two different styles (Northern Style, Southern Style, Brother Jimmy’s Dry Rub Ribs), or a “lil’ of each”
BBQ Chicken & Ribs—One-quarter BBQ chicken and three ribs; either northern, southern or dry rub style
Sliced Brisket—With two trimmings, cornbread and pickles
Pulled Pork Sandwich—North or South Carolina Style
Frickles—Fried pickles with horseradish sauce
Bucket O’ Hot Wings—Buffalo style, Chipotle BBQ or mustard; served with blue cheese and celery
Delicious bbq
Posted 2 months ago by Kevin M.
For the price? Not worth it. The mac and cheese was very good. The meats (chicken, ribs) were just ok. Corn bread: awful. Fried Green Tomatoes: flavorless.
Posted 5 months ago by Amanda F.
A bit expensive, but quite yummy. Cobb Salad is excellent with Honey Mustard dressing. Must request it specially, as it's not available as a radio button. Pulled Pork is good too, plus they give all sauces to try.
Posted a year ago by Qbradley W.
Disapointed .. not worth the money !!!. Food was passable but not good quality and there were things missing from the order
Posted a year ago by Richard A.
Quick delivery and good packaging
Posted 2 years ago by Ashley A.
Only select user reviews are published on SeamlessWeb. All user-submitted ratings contribute to Brother Jimmy`s BBQ (8th Ave)'s overall SeamlessWeb rating, but we manually screen all reviews and only publish those that are relevant and helpful. Tips for getting your review published »
Above content provided by restaurant.
Enter your address to start your order.
Click a menu item to add it to your order.
Learn more about Liked Items »
Back to top